A few days ago
Sophie Andrelica

Can you say, “How is the food going?”?

I think that it is ok to say, “How is the food going?” when wondering about the preparation of dinner at the present time. I think a logical response would be, “The food is going well.”

My bf say that that is wrong and I should say, “How is the food coming along?” He said something about, “using a present continuous verb not an adverb”…. I am not even sure what this means…

I’m wondering if some grammar fanatics could help me out here?

Thanks

Top 5 Answers
A few days ago
Who’s sarcastic?

Favorite Answer

Neither is appropriate considering the food isn’t going anywhere, nor is it coming.

If you want to use the vernacular, your bf uses a more common phrasing.

0

A few days ago
drivenmusicnyc
Well, grammaticaly you can say either one. Going is a present continuous verb, and so is “coming”, although I don’t think that’s the proper term for it, but whatever– they’re the same thing. “Well” is the adverb and it is involved in either answer. The food is going well. The food is coming along well.

“How is the food going?” sounds unnatural, because generally we use the phrase “x is going well” to describe an action, a process, or something “on-going” and continuous (A job, school, something that takes awhile). “Food” is not an action or a process, it’s an end result or a goal. We refer to goals as “coming along” because there is an end result (a meal) that will be completed in the near future.

For example, if you were building a house, it would be most natural to say “How is the work going?” and “How is the house coming along?” The house is the end result so it’s coming along (into your final possession) and the work of building it is a process that is going (like imagine it on a timeline, going down the line).

Anyway, both are grammatically correct, but yes, your friend’s versions sounds natural for colloquial reasons.

1

A few days ago
Mel
The problem is that when you say “how is the food going,” I don’t know if you mean how is the preparation going, how is your digestion going, how does it taste, etc. “How is the food coming along” is much easier to understand.
1

A few days ago
TurtleFromQuebec
Depends on the direction of the food. Is it coming or going?

… seriously, I think both ways are fine!

0

A few days ago
Anonymous
Grammatically, it’s fine to say “How is the food going?” But I think his alternative sounds more natural.
1