A few days ago
Anonymous

Dear grammar experts, please help me with these questions?

I need a savior. I am so confused. PLease, help >_< I thank you in advance FIRST QUESTION: Is it correct to use an infinitive or a gerund after a preposition? What are the rules for this? e.g. She has the skills required to make crafts. She has the skills required in making crafts. Is "involved to (make crafts)" a correct idiomatic expression? or is "involved in (making crafts)" the only correct form? SECOND QUESTION: Which is the correct idiomatic expression?-- "necessary for" or "necessary in" ( or are both correct?) e.g. This is necessary in/for each of these cases. THIRD QUESTION: Are these forms grammatically correct?-- "She is recognized more as a teacher than a writer" "She is recognized more as a teacher than as a writer" "She is recognized more as a teacher than writer." (Is the "as" or the "a" necessary? FOURTH QUESTION: Is "what" a pronoun? e.g. ...the lost city, what is now called Atlantis. (Is this sentence grammatically correct?)

Top 4 Answers
A few days ago
pandulfi

Favorite Answer

1: Infinitive.

2: In most cases, it’ll be “necessary for”. The only time I can think of that “in” would be appropriate would be when it simply qualified:

“It is necessary in this country”, which could equally be “In this country, it is necessary”.

3: All three are correct, but the third one sounds a little imbalanced. If you’re going to use an article for one, you should probably use it for all items in a list like that.

4: No (or rather, it is a pronoun, but shouldn’t be used to refer to the antecedent in that way). It ought to be “the lost city that is now called Atlantis”

0

A few days ago
hello molly
1. necessary to make crafts

2. This is a necessary situation in each of these cases. Or

This is necessary for each of these situations to occur.

3. keep it parallel

She is recognized more as a teacher than as a writer.

4. the lost city, that is now called…

0

A few days ago
aaron_n_az
I agree with bparker.
0

A few days ago
bparker1311
infinitives

for

as a

which would be better, but “what” is a pronoun as well

1