A few days ago
Cassie J

US History, Anyone????? Help needed!?

The war for independence and the vietnam war…How are they similar? Is America during the Vietnam war like Britain during the War for Independence? Why? Any answers, or partial answers would be VERY useful….Best answer to person w/most info!!!

Top 3 Answers
A few days ago
Anonymous

Favorite Answer

I think you could make a SLIGHT case for the Vietnamese fighting the FRENCH after WWII being similar to the American Revolution. The French had colonized that portion of the world and it was known as French Indochina (Cambodia, Laos, Vietnam – then Tonkin, Annam, Cochin China).

In WWII, that area was occupied by the Japanese. IT was returned to the French after the war, but the people there didn’t want them back. So, they went to war over it (First Indochina war). The Viet Mihn won a huge battle in 1954 (Dien Bien Phu) which led to the French withdrawal from the region — and the partitioning of North and South Vietnam. The North communist (which, btw, the U.S. supported against the Japanese in WWII) and the South, now supported by the U.S. So, in the sense that it was the people living there trying to overthrow the colonizing nation, yes, there is a tenuous tie. However, it would have been a much stronger tie had it been the Native Americans who had revolted against the British (which included the eventual Americans).

I would not say that the Vietnam War (2nd Indochina War) was similar to the revolution because the U.S. was technically there at the invitation of the South Vietnamese government. — a sovereign country.

Ironically, FDR had stated that the French was the worst colonizing power in the world and that he would see to it that they did NOT get Indochina back after the war. Unfortunately, Truman wanted French support after the war, and France wanted Indochina back. The rest is, pardon the pun, history.

0

A few days ago
imrt70
The Vietamese lived in Vietnam for FAR longer than the Americans had lived in America. I don’t believe our terrain was THAT much different than Britain’s. But, us going to Vietnam, we went wayyy out of our element….we were sitting ducks at times.

Britain also came to conquer us, whereas, we only wanted to teach Vietnam a lesson. (There’s no longer conquering done in any war we enter).

0

A few days ago
Ancient Warrior DogueDe Bordeaux
During the revolution colonial Americans were the hometown guerrillas, in Vietnam that scenario was the other way around, along with tactical superiority, money, transportation, communications, allies…..but we still managed to win, and so did the commies.
0