A few days ago
tangerine

Do some college courses feel sort of like high school classes to you?

I have a B.A. in Spanish with a minor in German. I have a passion for foreign languages, but I remember that when I was in college and I was taking some beginner-level language courses, they sort of felt like high school classes more than anything. Not only that, but I kind of found the cartoon pictures in the textbooks and the workbooks annoying, as well. I can’t help but think that college is somehow supposed to be more solemn than high school, and this sort of thing shoots that all to hell. What are your thoughts?

Top 10 Answers
A few days ago
Anonymous

Favorite Answer

Yes. Especially foreign languages because they are teaching such basics at the beginning levels that the textbooks steal tactics from 3 year olds in teaching colors, and foods and things like that.
1

A few days ago
Anonymous
I had to take a remedial algebra class in college and yeah, it was a bit juvenile. But looking back, it was probably the only class that seem high-schoolish. My instructor was a former Jr. High teacher, so it only made sense I guess.

Yeah, cartoons in the workbooks sounds pretty childish. LoL Oh well. Look where it took you though. A B.A. in Spanish and a minor in German. Not too shabby I’d say.

As for college being a more somber place. I disagree. I think it should be what it is. Since students are young adults, it needs to remain open to giving the student the freedom to make adult decisions and express opinions. It’s much freer than high school I think, because adults are expected to “choose” the path of higher learning, unlike teens who, in many cases, would rather choose the path of least resistance. LoL

1

A few days ago
Thomas M
Honestly, this is a good way to learn foreign languages for real, rather than to learn to translate in your head.

College should be harder than high school, but there’s no reason for it to be more solemn. If learning can be done at a rapid pace, with “fun” materials, that’s fine.

I do have concerns that a lot of the modern textbooks for science courses have way too many pictures and colored boxes, and are generally too wordy. I think sometimes these bits intended to help students are actually distracting.

1

A few days ago
Jen
I think it depends on the teacher. When learning a language, they do start off easy, and they do have cartoon pictures, but how else would you know what the heck a “mesa” is? I have had one class though, an English class, where the teacher had us all stand up and stretch in the middle of class. She ended up being one of the WORST teachers ever!
1

A few days ago
Aliz
When I was learning some Spanish from a Spanish speaking only person and I knew no Spanish it helped both of us to learn when we used stick pictures or pictures in a book to be able to communicate. And then we went from Spanish to English and English to Spanish dictionaries. That way we each heard the correct pronunciation of the words.
1

A few days ago
Rachel
I think things like that help beginners learn better. It’s silly to expect a beginning language book to have the same layout as an advanced language books.
3

A few days ago
jateef
Why don’t you get yourself some of those old grammar-translation books from the 60’s? Those are plenty solemn.

Or you could just frown at the cartoons.

I think the cartoons come from the philosophy that post-laterization second language learning should be interactive, engaging, communicative.

I’m sorry those cartoons pissed you off so much.

1

A few days ago
khrome_wind
The reason is that a good bit of the basics are never learned in high school….
1

A few days ago
Matsukaze
Some colleges feel like nusery schools to me.

No one pays attention, and the whole damn college is a joke.

1

A few days ago
Blair V
honestly…I think all of your basics ARE high school classes. it’s like being there again but in 2 years as apposed to 4.
1