A few days ago
Anonymous

What will happen to my friend?

Ok, I am a 19 year old boy, and my friend, he is 20 and he has special needs (social and emotional issues), and he did not understand the consquences of what he did, and did not understand what he did was wrong. He punched a college administrator, and also lied on government forms, etc. (State: NY) His parents are defending him on this (he is special needs), as they will not have him sent to jail (he is special needs). Will they understand, that he cannot handle jail, and what will they do, like community service or house arrest w/ parents to supervise? I am so worried for my friend. Please explain and let me know.

Top 3 Answers
A few days ago
TeacherLady

Favorite Answer

It depends on what type of disability your friend has, whether or not he’s been in trouble before, and what exactly he’s done.

Is he so disabled that he didn’t know that punching someone and lying are wrong? If he has the ability to go to college I have to wonder how truly impaired he is.

A disability is not an excuse for bad behavior! If your friend is incapable of understanding that punching someone and lying is unacceptable behavior then maybe he needs to be in a special home/institution somewhere with trained people who can deal with this, not out in the general population (especially on a college campus) where other people can get hurt.

Your friend needs to accept responsibility for his actions, serve out his consequences, and get the counseling, medication, or whatever help is necessary so this doesn’t happen again. Just saying that he is “special needs” does not get him off the hook and does not give him license to do whatever he wants to. It’s cases and parents like this that give special education students and their issues a bad reputation.

It’s time for your friend to grow up and face the music. If he’s got too many special needs to understand what he’s doing then he doesn’t need to be in college, or anywhere in society. Would you want to be in line behind him at the bank and have him turn around and hit you? Would you want to wait on him at a store and have him beat you up if something rings up incorrectly? Absolutely not, and it’s wrong to put others in danger because of your friend.

I know this may not be the answer that you want to hear, but it’s true. You don’t have to stop being his friend – your support is important to him – but take an objective look at the situation, and stay out of it. He is legally an adult, and he is responsible for his own behavior.

0

A few days ago
sm bn
you are a friend in need, a friend indeed!

What a great concern and frienship

wish you both a well lived life

no need to worry, I hope the state have good wisdom and give him a good judgement

1

A few days ago
Thinkaboutit
He will probably not serve time in jail because of his status. Wish the best for all of you.
1