A few days ago
phlygirl

which is right?

“have you seen the kid who took my pencil?” or

“have you seen the kid what took my pencil?” i hear the first one in the u.s. and the second one in the u.k…..which one do you guys say is the right way to say it?

Top 6 Answers
A few days ago
kirun

Favorite Answer

“who” is correct… “what” in this context would be considered incorrect in UK English; it is a fairly common error.
0

A few days ago
MinaMay
“who took my pencil” is grammatically correct for both the U.S. and the U.K. A kid is a person, and so “what” does not make any sense, “who” implies a person, and so is correct. The second one is just slang.
1

A few days ago
pa625
who took my pencil the other one does not make sence~
1

A few days ago
Anonymous
The first one, of course.
0

A few days ago
leluuu
who is question for living things and what for subjects, i guess 🙂
0

A few days ago
SiberiaROCKS
of cause first one…
0