A few days ago
♥Barbie♥

Quote 3- How do you feel about this one? religiously, emotionally, pyhisically, mentally…?

“I would rather have a mind opened by wonder than one closed by belief”

~Gerry Spence

Top 10 Answers
A few days ago
ARMY WIFE

Favorite Answer

When the human mind is open to suggestion it is free to explore and to enjoy adventure. Where as if the mind is closed you will find complacence. New things become old when nothing new is acheived. Belief is a good thing, it keeps us grounded and strong. Being open minded is what keeps us alive and going. I have come to these conclusions from life expirence. No matter what I believe I must keep an open mind.
1

A few days ago
masince1986
Wow, Barbie. It looks like you have really stirred up a can of worms with your question. I looked up Gerry Spence and his works and some of his quotes, and I’ll bet that he is loving the responses given here. He is a lawyer and author, among other things, and a very interesting person. Having learned of him, and having read the synopses of his books, I am anxious to read some of his work.

In one of his books, “Give Me Liberty”, he says “My intent is to tell the truth as I know it, realizing that what is true for me may be blasphemy for others.” Now that is actually not so profound a thought, though it is profound that he would make such a statement. He is at the same time granting everyone to believe as they will, yet challenging them to think deeply enough to be able to identify and express what it is they actually do really believe.

And he sure hit the jackpot with the quote you presented to us. Just observe what a range of responses it has stimulated, and how difficult it is for most respondents to clarify how they interpret the quote. I am most anxious to see which answer you select as best, because I am interested to learn how YOU interpret the quote. You had so many addendums to your question that it is obvious that you are either thoroughly confused or totally apologetic for even asking. Thanks for an interesting evening.

1

A few days ago
?
Intellectually, I think any challenge to intellect is great, like exercise is for the body. The quote makes you think.

Religiously, I oppose it.

Emotionally, it kinda torks me off, it’s rather arrogant.

Physically it makes my hair stand on end, and my blood pressure go up.

Mentally, I think Gerry Spence is implying that you can’t believe in God and have an open mind, or be curious, or intelligent enough to question the world, and your own beliefs.

Horse Puckey.

1

A few days ago
Experto Credo
Let us say taht you believe in mermaids.

Somewhere out there, Ariel and her sisters are swimming about, playing tag with the dolphins, exploring sunken ships, writing a history of great merfolk and their bravery.

Now, what if it was scientifically proven that mermaids do not exist and could never exist?

a little bit of me has died. Cold, heartless science (in this case) has dashed to bits an imaginative and fanciful notion. And to what end or purpose?

The reach of the mind is limitless and it should NOT be shut off for whatever reason.

Keep your science; I’ll keep my Ariel.

1

A few days ago
Anonymous
I don’t know… I don’t really like it. Just because your mind is opened by wonder does not mean it’s good for you. I mean, people are curious or wonder about drugs, try it, and then are addicted for life. If you have strong beliefs, and know what’s good for you and not, then you might have an easier time avoiding trouble.

It seems to be a pretty anti-religious quote anyway… which also bothers me. People who put down religion just seem very negative and cynical.

1

A few days ago
Anonymous
Excellent. And not new… have a look at the philosophers of the 18th century in France, inspired themselves by classic Greek Democracy (big friends of the early American constitution and scientific analysis). Reason versus Bigotry …
1

A few days ago
friendlyadvice
It’s commentary on how the man-made rules of religion have closed so many minds to the true wonder and beauty that is God and the universe.
2

A few days ago
Anonymous
It’s very true. How many times have old beliefs been shattered? At one time they believed that man could never fly because he didn’t have wings.
2

A few days ago
Anonymous
It is better to have an open mind because your beliefs will not be so narrow minded. God Bless.
2

A few days ago
2bzy
Absolutely! Happened to me… my mind was closed by belief, but then I started to wonder–mind opened!
2