A few days ago
Anonymous

I have a high school student who is very quiet?

I’m a pre-calculus teacher and I have a 16 year old girl in one of my classes. I had her last year as a student as well. Last year she was very quiet, but this year she seems even more quiet and is very shy. She won’t talk to anyone and when someone tries talking to her she replies, but very quietly and she looks really nervous to talk to anyone. Whenever I glance over at her she always looks very distressed. But she’s a very hardworker and gets all of her work done and is very thourough. I just don’t know why she’s so scared around people. What do you guys think? I decided to ask this in adolescent since teens may be able to give me some insight.

Top 5 Answers
A few days ago
DrIG

Favorite Answer

It is intelligent for you to ask other teenagers for their opinions and to go outside of your school so that the girl is not embarrassed.

You have to date received excellent answers. It is good that you are concerned.

You may also want to:

1. Contact her guidance counselor.

2. Contact her parents.

3. Speak to the girl and directly and in a kindly manner ask her what you can do to help.

I remember an oriental bright student who I had many years ago that was also very quiet and did his work very well. I am sorry to this day that I did not try to help him.He would up in a mental hospital. I do not know the ending but upon later thought I felt that pressure from home to do well in school was at least part of the reason.

1

A few days ago
old lady
I had a young woman like that in one of my classes – an excellent student, but very, very quiet. A little investigation showed it to be cultural – in her culture, women didn’t speak out, didn’t draw attention to themselves. I found ways to praise her work, and to help her when help was needed, without drawing attention to her unduly, and that helped a lot.

The problem may lie with her family – if not in a cultural arena, in the interaction between members of her family. There is also the possibility that she is the victim of abuse. It might be worth mentioning to the school psychologist, or the district psychologist, to get an idea of how you should approach her.

3

A few days ago
?
You seem to be a very good teacher! Actually, she is exactly like me! I’m real shy around people, but finish my hmwk every day and get good marks. Well… I guess people like me and her like to study alone rather than working in a group or talking to other people. It just works better for me and feel comfortable because I don’t know what to talk to other people. Do not force her to talk, but praise when she is doing a good job. It would make her feel more comfortable and relaxed.
3

A few days ago
apetkw
well, help her but don’t force her into it. It’s a natural trait.

If she just started becoming distressed ever since she came to school, maybe it’s something that’s not school related that she hasn’t gotten over yet or maybe she wants to keep her privacy.

If you really, really want to talk to her make an appointment after class and discuss it. If she doesn’t want to let her go.

3

A few days ago
Anonymous
Be nice to her but do not make it look like you are trying to be nice to her just because she is quiet or you think she is “special”.

I can think of little else that would make this girl more embarrsed than being singled out based on the way you describe her.

Just be nice to her.

3